New Jersey Stage logo
New Jersey Stage Menu



 

REVIEW: Make Sure You Catch Peter and the Star Catcher

By Shelley Bromberg, MsBrom.Com

originally published: 10/10/2016


One of the many benefits of theatre in New Jersey is having the opportunity to see a great performance of a play locally that you missed while it was running on Broadway. Such is the case with the Growing Stage and its current New Jersey professional premiere of five-time Tony Award® winning play, Peter and the Star Catcher, at the Historic Palace Theatre in Netcong.

Written by Rick Elice, Peter and the Star Catcher is based on the best-selling novel, Peter and the Starcatchers, by Dave Barry and Ridley Pearson and directed by Roger Rees and Alex Timbers with music by Wayne Barker. This musical prequel answers the age-old question: How exactly did Peter Pan become The Boy Who Never Grew Up?

No surprise, then, that on its opening night, The Growing Stage’s Children’s Theatre of New Jersey kicks off its 35th season with an audience filled with smiling adults and children who are very excited and eager to learn more about a beloved character from their childhoods. 

In tonight’s performance, both children and adults journey on a fantastic trip back to the Queen Victorian era of 1885. It is evident through much applause, laughter, and children’s giggles that they are delighting in pillaging pirates, jungle savages, colorful mermaids, magical elements, and lost and found treasures. The audience joyfully takes in the creative use of pantomime, props, puppets, and simple materials used to create ocean waves.

There are about a dozen actors in this production who bring over 100 characters to life. The ensemble is strong and energetic and the action is fast-paced. Most notable are actors Josh Carpenter (Black Stache), who enlivens the stage with his humorous antics and Davis Lemley, who honestly portrays a believable lost orphan who will eventually find his voice and name, Peter. 




Promote your shows at New Jersey Stage! Click here for info



In addition to Carpenter, the cast features a strong array of EQUITY actors including Izzy Figueroa (Sanchez/Fighting Prawn), Jeremy William Hilgert (Bill Slank/Hawking Clam), Lucas Pinner (Mack/Grempkin), and Richard Stillman (Smee/Gregors).

Nikki Miller beautifully brings to life the role of energetic Molly Aster, and Julie Galorenzo is to be commended for her lively portrayals of Mrs. Brumbrake and Teacher. Rounding out the ensemble is Robert Allan (Lord Aster), Stephen Fox (Captain Scott), Dalton Allison (Prentice), and Justin Watt (Ted).

The play is cleverly directed by Stephen L. Fredericks, The Growing Stage’s Executive Director. The cast is strong on the musical numbers, which can be attributed to the effective musical direction of Stephen Fox. Jillian Petrie does a fine job with lively and energetic choreography. 

Fourth graders, Delaney and Roisin, were giggling and taking in the humor throughout the performance. When asked during intermission what they enjoy most, Delaney reveals that she likes the funny character of Black Stache. Roisin states that she loves Molly because, “She is kind and can do anything with the star dust.” Clearly, it is a family-friendly and fun event for kids and parents who are eager to use their imaginations!

For those of you not familiar with the Historic Palace Theatre, it has a rich and vibrant history of its own. Built in 1919, the theatre has been a noteworthy entertainment venue for over 50 years. 

According to the Growing Stage’s website, the theatre first began showing silent movies and vaudeville shows, and it was later used for community events. In the mid-1930’s, actors of the day — Celeste Holm, Gale Sondergaard, and Bert Lytell — performed as a troupe first here and then later on the Great White Way.

The Growing Stage purchased the Palace in 1995 and has worked vigorously on the building’s restoration, raising and re-investing over $2 million in the project. 




Promote your shows at New Jersey Stage! Click here for info



The facility is listed on the National Registers of Historic Places. It can fully seat 240 patrons and the balcony and art gallery is adorned with beautiful murals painstakingly completed by Perry Arthur Kroeger, company artist-in-resident.

Peter and the Star Catcher runs through October 23 and performances are Fridays at 7:30 and Saturdays and Sundays at 4:00. The upcoming season includes a Halloween Magic Show starring Morley the Magician and the ever-popular A Christmas Carol, the musical running November 18-December 18. For tickets or more information go to www.growingstage.com. 

PHOTOS BY Jerry Dalia


For more by Shelley Bromberg, visit MsBrom.Com

About the author: Shelley Bromberg, www.MsBrom.com

EVENT PREVIEWS

(HADDON TOWNSHIP, NJ) -- The Ritz Theatre Company continues its Cabaret Series with Dream On! on Wednesday, July 1, 2026 at 7:30pm. Curated by Connor Twigg, this event features regional artists singing songs from their dream roles.
Liberty Arts Theatre presents "The America 250 USO Tour" featuring a star-studded cast from Abraham Lincoln to Thomas Jefferson with music, dance, comedy and after party!

Liberty Arts Theatre presents "The America 250 USO Tour" featuring a star-studded cast from Abraham Lincoln to Thomas Jefferson with music, dance, comedy and after party!

(LEONIA, NJ) -- Liberty Arts Theatre will keep us all rockin' in the free world with the high-octane celebration America 250 USO Tour - where Vaudeville meets American history – featuring a star-studded cast from Abraham Lincoln and Thomas Jefferson to George Patton, a live orchestra, song-and-dance numbers and comedy sketches. The America 250 USO Tour will march into the American Legion Post #1 (399 Broad Street) in Leonia on Thursday, July 2, 2026 at 7:00pm.
Classic American Tales honors the 250th with "Margaret

Classic American Tales honors the 250th with "Margaret's Diary During a Revolution"

(CAPE MAY, NJ) -- "Before we retired to bed, an attempt was made to teach the children to pronounce 'vegates,' (how do you do?) like a German. Our good neighbors are a little concerned to think there is not one in the neighborhood who will be able to interpret for us when the Hessians are quartered here," wrote Margaret Morris in her diary on December 21, 1776.
American Theater Group and Union Arts Center present Spotlight on NJ: Play Reading Event

American Theater Group and Union Arts Center present Spotlight on NJ: Play Reading Event

(UNION, NJ) -- American Theater Group (ATG), in partnership with the Union Arts Center, will present a three-day Spotlight play reading event featuring works by New Jersey playwrights at the DMK Black Box Theater at the Union Arts Center from July 6-8, 2026 with performances at 7:00pm each night.

Live On Stage Productions presents "Together Off-Broadway: Merman & Martin in Concert" at Cape May Stage

(CAPE MAY, NJ) -- Live On Stage Productions presents Together Off-Broadway: Merman & Martin in Concert at Cape May Stage from July 4-10, 2026. This show celebrates the remarkable bond between Ethel Merman and Mary Martin — two of Broadway’s brightest stars.

Gateway Playhouse presents Neil Simon's "London Suite"

(SOMERS POINT, NJ) -- Gateway Playhouse presents Neil Simon's London Suite with three performances from July 11-12, 2026. Witty, charming, and unmistakably Neil Simon, London Suite invites audiences into a series of hilarious and heartfelt encounters set in the same London hotel room.

The Light Opera of New Jersey presents "H.M.S. Pinafore" at the Sieminski Theater Cultural Arts Center

(BASKING RIDGE, NJ) -- The Light Opera of New Jersey presents H.M.S. Pinafore from July 11-12, 2026 at the Sieminski Theater Cultural Arts Center. This is a comic operetta by Gilbert and Sullivan that satirize the British class system. 
Misfits Theatre Co. presents "She Loves Me"

Misfits Theatre Co. presents "She Loves Me"

(MATAWAN, NJ) -- Misfits Theatre Co., a community theater organization dedicated to producing bold, entertaining, and accessible theater for audiences of all ages, presents its inaugural book musical production, She Loves Me at Matawan Regional High School from July 10-12, 2026.
Dragonfly Multicultural Arts Center presents "Sense and Sensibility" outside duCret Center of Art

Dragonfly Multicultural Arts Center presents "Sense and Sensibility" outside duCret Center of Art

(PLAINFIELD, NJ) -- Dragonfly Multicultural Arts Center invites audiences to experience Jane Austen's beloved classic Sense and Sensibility in a charming outdoor production this summer at duCret Center of Art in Plainfield. Performances take place July 10-12, 2026.

Howell PAL Theater Company presents "Grease"

(OCEAN GROVE, NJ) -- Howell PAL Theater Company presents the classic musical Grease weekends from July 10-12, 2026 at the Jersey Shore Arts Center. Grease is a love song to the 1950s and a cornerstone of the American musical comedy form.

 

FEATURED EVENTS


Spamalot

Sunday, June 28, 2026 @ 6:30pm
State Theatre New Jersey
New Brunswick, NJ


Spamalot

Sunday, June 28, 2026 @ 1:00pm
State Theatre New Jersey
New Brunswick, NJ


Vivid Summer Solos: "Fair Stage" by Megan Gogerty

Wednesday, July 08, 2026 @ 6:30pm
Visual Arts Center of New Jersey
Summit, NJ


My Fair Lady

Friday, July 10, 2026 @ 7:00pm
Grunin Center - Main Stage
Toms River, NJ


The Little Mermaid

Friday, July 10, 2026 @ 7:00pm
Middletown Arts Center
Middletown, NJ