By Bruce Chadwick
originally published: 02/11/2024
Destinee Rea and Stanley Martin in After Midnight © Evan Zimmerman for Murphy Made
(MILLBURN, NJ) -- The musical After Midnight opens slowly as a singer wails about long bread lines in Harlem, in New York City, everywhere in America. She sings on about the awful state of affairs in America, the Great Depression.
Then, with a big BOUNCE, the play about Harlem and its nightlife in the 1920s and 1930s opens.
After Midnight Is beautiful. It is titanic. It is lovable. A single word to describe the play, is WOW.
After Midnight is a real triumph for the Paper Mill Playhouse, in Millburn, where it just opened. What is it, anyway, though?
Is it the story of people in Harlem during the Depression? No.
Is it the love story of a Harlem couple struggling through the Depression? No.
One single man, or woman, story of hope and survival?
No, not that either.
The musical that recently opened at the Paper Mill is not any of those. It is a charming (no Devilish!) play about New York and its night life in the Depression with a lot of artistry, no, magic, The wonder of it is that it has no solid plot, but its several dozen songs and dance numbers tell you all need to know about entertainment in that era, and its stars. It is not one big story, as so many musicals are, but several dozen little stories, each with its own stars and director, and music, music, music!
Aramie Payton, Angela Birchett, and Anthony Wayne in After Midnight © Evan Zimmerman for Murphy Made
You will love this play for its marvelous songs, such as “Stormy Weather,” just as good now as when it was first recorded. You will love it for its actors and actresses who bring all of these historic figures to life. You will love the play, very neatly conceived by Jack Viertel and for its superb direction by the supremely gifted Dominique Kelley and Jen Bender, and for the sometimes smooth and sometimes soaring choreography by Ms. Kelley (these folks can dance!)
The play is a wonderful look back at both entertainment and history, all told with music on a small stage (the orchestra moves in and out according to the song).
The songs (many by Duke Ellington), and performers tell the story of Harlem in that turbulent era, and New York, and the United State in a new and tantalizing way. You are hooked early and brought into the story of the folks of Harlem, and the city, back then.
The stories are all different, but all tied to the age-old boy meets girl saga, as powerful in old Athens as it is today. Will they fall in love? Will he leave her? Will she leave him? Will anybody care? Won’t everybody care?
Stanley Martin, Destinee Rea, Liv Symone, Sasha Hutchings, and Harris Matthew in After Midnight © Jeremy Daniel
The play features many hit songs of that era, such as “Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea,” “I’ve Got the World on a String,” “ I Can’t Gove You Anything but Love,””Stormy Weather, “On the Sunny Side of the Street,”” It Don’t Mean a Thing” and “The Cotton Club Stomp.” All of that and they even have that classic “Take the A Train.”
The co-directors develop each small story individually and then, with some magic dust, tie them all together as an American story. They do superb work and have created a simply terrific play.
What amazed me was how the co-directors managed to get all these stories on to a single stage, and with a full orchestra, with, oh, six million dancers, twirling about at the same time, and in those, dazzling, just smashing costumes. You sit there in the audience, constantly tapping your feet, and truly believe you are back at the rocking’ and poppin’ fabled Cotton Club with Duke Ellington, Harold Arlen, E.Y. Harburg and an army of singers and dancers strutting their stuff and doing so right in front of you.
Harris Matthew in After Midnight © Evan Zimmerman for Murphy Made
Best part of the musical? Nowhere, nowhere, nowhere, is there a photo or mention of Taylor Swift. Thank God for that.
After Midnight is presented at Paper Mill Playhouse (22 Brookside Drive in Millburn, New Jersey) through February 25, 2024. Runtime is 90 minutes, no intermission.
For more information or to purchase tickets, click here.
Aramie Payton and Destinee Rea in After Midnight © Jeremy Daniel
About the author:
Bruce Chadwick worked for 23 years as an entertainment writer/critic for the New York Daily News. Later, he served as the arts and entertainment critic for the History News Network, a national online weekly magazine. Chadwick holds a Ph. D in History and Cultural Studies from Rutgers University. He has written 31 books on U.S. history and has lectured on history and culture around the world. He is a history professor at New Jersey City University.
EVENT PREVIEWS
Gas Lamp Teens present "Fame: The Musical"
(GLEN RIDGE, NJ) -- Gas Lamp Teens present Fame: The Musical on August 7-8, 2026 at the Ridgewood Avenue School. Fame has inspired generations to fight for fame and light up the sky like a flame!
Two River Theater presents ¡Festejo! Celebrating Latine Stories Onstage
(RED BANK, NJ) -- Two River Theater presents the 15th anniversary of ¡Festejo! Celebrating Latine Stories Onstage, from August 6–9, 2026. Curated by José Zayas, the annual festival, formerly known as Crossing Borders (Cruzando Fronteras), will feature five new play readings by acclaimed and emerging Latine playwrights.
Gateway Playhouse to Hold Open Auditions for "9 to 5: The Musical"
(SOMERS POINT, NJ) -- Gateway Playhouse of Somers Point is holding open auditions for their third MainStage production of the year, the incredibly fun 9 to 5: The Musical. Auditions will take place from 6:00pm-8:00pm Monday and Tuesday, August 10 and 11, 2026. All roles are open and any performance experience is welcomed (must be 16 or older).
Middlesex County Plays-in-the-Park to Host Auditions for "Curious George: The Golden Meatball" on August 12th
(EDISON, NJ) -- Middlesex County's Plays-in-the-Park is holding auditions for its fall 2026 children's production of Curious George: The Golden Meatball on Wednesday, August 12, at 6:00pm at the Stephen J. Capestro Theatre located inside Roosevelt Park in Edison. Everyone's favorite mischievous monkey and his friend in the yellow hat sing and dance up a storm in this adventure-filled musical.
Chimera Productions presents "Job" at Paul Robeson Center for the Arts
(PRINCETON, NJ) -- New Jersey-based theater company Chimera Productions will present its 17th production, Job by Max Wolf Friedlich, from August 13-15, 2026 at 8:00pm each night. The play, presented in the intimate 60-seat theater inside Princeton's Paul Robeson Center for the Arts, is a psychological thriller that offers a sharp, darkly funny, and unsettling examination of our addiction to work, the internet, the cost of modern life, and what we're willing to sacrifice to belong.
Villagers Theatre's TeensVill program presents "The Wedding Singer"
(SOMERSET, NJ) -- Villagers Theatre's TeensVill program presents The Wedding Singer across two weekends from August 7-16, 2026. Based on the popular movie, the play takes place in New Jersey in 1985. A wannabe rock star (aka a professional wedding singer) is left at the altar and finally changes his tune.
The Levoy Theatre presents "Beautiful: The Carole King Musical"
(MILLVILLE, NJ) -- The Levoy Theatre presents Beautiful: The Carole King Musical across two weekends from August 7-16, 2026. This is the inspiring true story of Carole King's journey from teenage songwriter to the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame.
The Theater Project presents "Alabama Story" by Kenneth Jones
(UNION, NJ) -- The Theater Project will wrap up its 2026 summer season with the first New Jersey production of Kenneth Jones's Alabama Story, about the clash between censorship and civil rights in the Jim Crow South, August 6-16 at the DMK Black Box Theatre. Alabama Story blends fact and fiction.
The Premier Theatre Company presents "Jesus Christ Superstar"
(RUMSON, NJ) -- The Premier Theatre Company presents Jesus Christ Superstar in the Rumson School District Auditorium across two weekends from August 7-16, 2026. This is a timeless work set against the backdrop of an extraordinary and universally-known series of events, but seen through the eyes of Judas Iscariot.
Spotlight Players present Roald Dahl's Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
(MATAWAN, NJ) -- Spotlight Players invites audiences of all ages to experience the wonder, imagination, and unforgettable music of Roald Dahl's Charlie and the Chocolate Factory when the Broadway musical runs across two weekends from August 7-16, 2026 for a limited six-performance engagement.
FEATURED EVENTS
