New Jersey Stage logo
New Jersey Stage Menu



 

PHOTOS from "It Shoulda Been You" at Old Library Theatre

By John Posada

originally published: 07/29/2022

(FAIR LAWN, NJ) -- Old Library Theatre (OLT), Fair Lawn Recreation Department’s resident theatre company is currently presenting the Broadway musical, It Shoulda Been You, at the Fair Lawn Community Center. The show will be presented over two weekends, starting Friday, July 29, and run through August 7th, with performances on Fridays and Saturdays at 8:00pm, and Sundays at 2:00pm. Photographer John Posada was at a dress rehearsal to take some photos.

It Shoulda Been You, written by Barbara Anselmi and Brian Hargrove, tells the story of two very different and comical families who have come together for a wedding ceremony. The theme of internal identities and external appearances, and the judgments that come from others, is central to the farcical musical. When it comes to wedding day insanity, it’s all relative. The culture clash of Rebecca’s Jewish family and Brian’s Catholic family takes center stage as the Bride, Groom, their families, and friends each bring their own modern spin to the traditional wedding comedy. The bride’s mother is controlling, and the groom’s mother just wants a steady flow of gin. When the bride’s ex-boyfriend shows up, chaos ensues, and it falls to the sister of the bride to turn a tangled mess into happily every after. 

The production is directed by Armanda Cerqueira, produced by Dawn Cardona, with music direction by Joseph Christenson, Choreography by Eliah Furlong, costumes by Amy Kurfist, props by Anthony Bevilacqua, set design by Patt Tanner, and with Jeff Parsons serving as the Stage Manager.

Director Armanda Cerqueira said “This show asks the audience to question all the 'Shoulds" that we as a society have made standard. The entertainment industry has maintained that actors should be of a certain size and a certain age. Even as we move towards more body inclusivity- there are still limits to how fat lead characters can be, and younger actors are often cast to play much older. What this ultimately does is put fantastically talented folks in the background. I wanted to tell this story through a more relatable lens. It Shoulda Been You can be anyone's story and every body should be able to tell it.” 

It Shoulda Been You stars Evan T Charpentier as the Bride’s sister and Co-Maid of Honor, Jenny; Nicholas Culver as the Bride’s ex-boyfriend, Marty; Melissa Broder and Robert Russell as the parents of the Bride; Danielle C Pennisi and Joshua Switala as the Bride and Groom; Annette Winter and Mark Dacey as the parents of the Groom; Melyssa Searcy and David Villa as the Co-Maid of Honor and Best Man; Joseph Pierone as the Wedding Coordinator; Michelle Ward and Matt Cavallo as Aunt Sheila and Uncle Morty; Sam Sz and Anthony Finke as Albert’s assistance; with Caitlin Greene, Amy Kurfist, Adam Mahonchak, and Nyasia Legra rounding out the hotel staff. 




Follow New Jersey Stage on social media
Facebook, Threads, Instagram, Twitter, Bluesky



 

Tickets are available for purchase online. Tickets are $23 for Adults, $20 for Seniors. Old Library Theatre is located at 10-10 20th Street in Fair Lawn, New Jersey. 

Here are more photos from the production.

The mission of Old Library Theatre is to provide quality entertainment at an affordable cost in Bergen County, showcasing talented artists, creators, and performers who represent the full spectrum of the human experience at all stages of development.



ALL PHOTOS BY JOHN POSADA - If your theatre company is interested in having John Posada cover your plays, contact New Jersey Stage at [email protected].  He has taken photos during live performances and dress rehearsals.




Follow New Jersey Stage on social media
Facebook, Threads, Instagram, Twitter, Bluesky



About the author:

John Posada is a New Jersey based photographer specializing in photographing live theatre and music performances. Currently, John has spent the last 6 years concentrating on photographing almost 400 theater productions at over 70 different NJ theatres. Click here for John's website.



EVENT PREVIEWS

(MADISON, NJ) -- The Shakespeare Theatre of New Jersey (STNJ) will present its 2026 holiday production, The Gifts of the Magi from December 5-31 at the F.M. Kirby Shakespeare Theatre in Madison. A heartwarming musical adaptation of the beloved stories by O. Henry, this enchanting production celebrates the spirit of generosity, devotion, and the true meaning of the season.
 

FEATURED EVENTS



A Beat of Our Own

Wednesday, October 21, 2026 @ 7:30pm
McCarter Theatre Center (Matthews Theatre)
91 University Place, Princeton, NJ


George Street Playhouse presents The Unexpected 3rd

Wednesday, October 21, 2026 @ 7:30pm
New Brunswick Performing Arts Center (NBPAC)
11 Livingston Avenue, New Brunswick, NJ


A Beat of Our Own

Thursday, October 22, 2026 @ 2:00pm
McCarter Theatre Center (Matthews Theatre)
91 University Place, Princeton, NJ


A Beat of Our Own

Thursday, October 22, 2026 @ 7:30pm
McCarter Theatre Center (Matthews Theatre)
91 University Place, Princeton, NJ


Premiere Stages at Kean presents Effa Loves Baseball

Thursday, October 22, 2026 @ 10:30am
Kean Stage - Enlow Recital Hall
215 North Avenue, Hillside, NJ