New Jersey Stage logo
New Jersey Stage Menu



 

REVIEW: Godspell at The Eagle Theatre

By Gary Wien

originally published: 11/30/2016


Chances are, you’ve never seen a production of Godspell like the one heading into its final 2 weeks at The Eagle Theatre.  Performed “In the Round,” the play lives in an entirely different atmosphere - one in which the audience is very much part of the show and the theatre becomes a virtual playground for the actors.  The end effect is like somewhere being part of a Church revival rather than simply watching one and seeing an episode of Schoolhouse Rock performed live on stage.

Eagle’s Godspell is an updated version of the classic musical featuring music by Stephen Schwartz which was a hit on Broadway in the early 1970s. The play explores the Jesus Christ story in a way you won’t find in Church.  Christ and his disciples learn and discuss parables, play games, and sing songs while the play leads ultimately to the crucifixion.  It’s one of the rock and roll inspired musicals that generally appeals to people who don’t like traditional musicals.

The updates incorporate mentions of movies from Star Wars to Indiana Jones to Lord of The Rings; adds a little rap music; and includes audience members in rounds of Pictionary and Charades.

“This presentation has been one I’ve been dreaming up for years,” explained Director Ted Wioncek III.  “My goal was to use a ‘story theatre’ style in order to provide freedom while using a range of high comedy and low puns, broad physical gags, meta theatrical anachronisms, and deep sentiment.  The script has been rewritten, the music revamped, actors play instruments, and the environment is immersive.”

According to Wioncek, Eagle is able to reconfigure its seating and sets as often as they see fit.  Normally this only affects the first few rows, but for Godspell it led to an entirely new experience.




Follow New Jersey Stage on social media
Facebook, Threads, Instagram, Twitter, Bluesky



The production includes a slew of actors making their return to The Eagle Theatre including Sal Pavia, Tim Rinehart, Rajeer Alford, Will Connell, Maggie Griffin-Smith, Cailene Kilcoyne, Loulou Luzi, Justin Mazzella, and Kimberly Suskind.  Rounding out the cast are a pair of newcomers to Eagle (Abigail Allwein and Madalyn St. John). Wioncek’s direction keeps everything moving quickly and utilizes both sides of the theatre well.  Considering some (if not all) of the actors are likely performing their first production “in the round” - they are tremendous in utilizing the space around them.

The cast, led by Sal Pavia as Christ is exceptional.  Sal is energetic, funny, and inspiring while the disciples all have the right blend of amazement, wonder, love, and dashes of being members of a cult.  Each cast member performs instruments live on stage, which looks and sounds terrific in the way the production is staged.  Some instruments and songs are literally performed next to the audience.  

The music is strong throughout but highlights for me included the wonderful “Day By Day” (which actually shook the room with applause, foot stomping, and dancing while music filled the theatre), “Learn Your Lessons Well,” “By My Side,” “Beautiful City,” and “On The Willows.”  While the room is full with beautiful guitars and drums, it’s worth highlighting the wonderful violin playing of Abigail Allwein which adds color to several songs.

In the end, Godspell is a tale about parables and lessons, and the dangers of failing to learn the messages.  You do not have to be religious at all to enjoy the music and comedy, but hopefully some of the messages will stay with you.  For me, the biggest take home was “If you only love those who love you, where is the extraordinary in that?”  The message of love your enemies is rather appropriate after such a divisive election as the one we just had.



Godspell runs Wednesday through Sunday, now through December 11.  The Eagle Theatre is located at 208 Vine Street in Hammonton. For more information visit www.theeagletheatre.com



This was our first time visiting The Eagle Theatre in Hammonton as we make our rounds through the dozens of professional theatres in the Garden State.  Hammonton appears to have a very cool downtown from what we saw.  There is a wonderful wine bar basically across the street from the theatre, a coffee shop, and several restaurants all within walking distance.  And speaking of wine, The Eagle Theatre has a wine bar inside its lobby for Sharrot Winery where you can purchase half or full bottles of wine from the local winery and enjoy before, during, or after the show.

 





Follow New Jersey Stage on social media
Facebook, Threads, Instagram, Twitter, Bluesky



About the author:

Gary Wien has been covering the arts since 2001 and has had work published with Jersey Arts, Upstage Magazine, Elmore Magazine, Princeton Magazine, Backstreets and other publications. He is a three-time winner of the Asbury Music Award for Top Music Journalist and the author of Beyond the Palace (the first book on the history of rock and roll in Asbury Park) and Are You Listening? The Top 100 Albums of 2001-2010 by New Jersey Artists. In addition, he runs New Jersey Stage and the online radio station The Penguin Rocks. His personal website is at lightyscorner.com. He can be contacted at [email protected].


EVENT PREVIEWS

(SOMERS POINT, NJ) -- Gateway Playhouse presents Neil Simon's London Suite with three performances from July 11-12, 2026. Witty, charming, and unmistakably Neil Simon, London Suite invites audiences into a series of hilarious and heartfelt encounters set in the same London hotel room.

The Light Opera of New Jersey presents "H.M.S. Pinafore" at the Sieminski Theater Cultural Arts Center

(BASKING RIDGE, NJ) -- The Light Opera of New Jersey presents H.M.S. Pinafore from July 11-12, 2026 at the Sieminski Theater Cultural Arts Center. This is a comic operetta by Gilbert and Sullivan that satirize the British class system. 
Pioneer Productions presents encore run of "What the Constitution Means to Me" in Chatham Borough

Pioneer Productions presents encore run of "What the Constitution Means to Me" in Chatham Borough

(CHATHAM, NJ) -- Pioneer Productions is thrilled to announce encore performances of their production of Heidi Schreck's "What the Constitution Means to Me." Following a sold-out run of the show in downtown Morristown earlier this year, the original cast and production team have partnered with Chatham Borough to present an encore weekend July 11-12, 2026 at the Stanely Center.

Skyline Theatre Company presents Shakespeare on the Porch with "Much Ado About Nothing"

(BLOOMFIELD, NJ) -- Skyline Theatre Company presents Much Ado About Nothing with performances July 17-18, 2026 as part of its Shakespeare on the Porch series. The Bard's ultimate rom-com comes to life on the porch of the Oakeside Mansion.

Main Street Theatre Company presents "The Music Man JR."

(OLD BRIDGE, NJ) -- Main Street Theatre Company presents The Music Man JR. across two weekends from July 11-19, 2026. There's trouble in River City when a fast-talking salesman gets his heart stolen by the town librarian in this adaptation of the Tony Award-winning Broadway classic.

Aspire Performing Arts Company presents Green Day's American Idiot

(MONTVILLE, NJ) -- Aspire Performing Arts Company presents Green Day's American Idiot from July 17-19, 2026 at the Barn Theatre. The band's powerhouse album is brought to life in this electric-rock musical of youthful disillusion. The production features two sets of casts.

The Theater Project presents "Too Fat For China" by Phoebe Potts

(UNION, NJ) -- The Theater Project presents Too Fat For China from July 17-19, 2026 in the DMK Black Box Theater. Comedian Phoebe Potts' one-woman show follows the surprises and painful realizations of her adoption journey with humor and candor.
Iron Mountain Stage Company presents "46 Plays For America

Iron Mountain Stage Company presents "46 Plays For America's First Ladies"

(RINGWOOD, NJ) -- Iron Mountain Stage Company presents 46 Plays For America's First Ladies from July 11-19, 2026. A biographical, meta-theatrical, genre-bending ride through race, gender, and everything else your history teacher never taught you about the founding of America.
"Chip and Gus" - a comedy with balls comes to Florham Park on July 20th

"Chip and Gus" - a comedy with balls comes to Florham Park on July 20th

(FLORHAM PARK, NJ) -- On Monday, July 20, 2026, Chip and Gus, a comedy with balls will be presented at The Thomas H. Kean Theatre Factory. The play is performed, directed, and created by John Ahlin & Christopher Patrick Mullen. Showtime is 7:30pm.
The Theater Project presents "Having Our Say" by Emily Mann

The Theater Project presents "Having Our Say" by Emily Mann

(UNION, NJ) -- The Theater Project's 2026 summer season will begin with a bang with a production of Having Our Say, Emily Mann’s 1995 Tony Award-nominated drama about "two 'maiden ladies' with century-old stories to tell", July 11-21, 2026 at the DMK Black Box Theatre.

 

FEATURED EVENTS


Shrek: The Musical

Saturday, July 11, 2026 @ 2:00pm
Algonquin Arts Theatre
Manasquan, NJ


My Fair Lady

Saturday, July 11, 2026 @ 7:00pm
Grunin Center - Main Stage
Toms River, NJ


The Little Mermaid

Saturday, July 11, 2026 @ 2:00pm
Middletown Arts Center
Middletown, NJ


IHCA-NJ presents Natya Darpan 2026

Saturday, July 11, 2026 @ 12:00pm
New Brunswick Performing Arts Center (NBPAC)
New Brunswick, NJ


Shrek: The Musical

Sunday, July 12, 2026 @ 3:00pm
Algonquin Arts Theatre
Manasquan, NJ