By Shen Shellenberger, JerseyArts.com
originally published: 12/07/2016
When it comes to the holidays, it is traditions – the people we spend time with, the places we go, and the special things we do – that create our most long-lasting and endearing memories.
In Cape May, “Yuletide Tales,” the East Lynne Theater Company’s annual holiday show, has become that kind of tradition.
Every winter for the past decade, Gayle Stahlhuth, Artistic Director for ELTC, has presented this unique one-person telling of stories, hand-picked and adapted from the rich treasury of American literature.
This year’s selections are “Snow Image” by Nathaniel Hawthorne (1804-1864), “9 Linwood Street” by Edward Everett Hale (1822-1909), “Susie’s Letter to Santa Clause” by Mark Twain (1835-1910) and “The Gift of the Magi” by O. Henry (1862-1910).
For many years, the ELTC did not present a special holiday show. “We were coming off our busy summer and fall schedule,” Stahlhuth said. “And we felt like Cape May already offered plenty of holiday entertainment options.”
But, with gathering stories for the “Victorian Tales” series, which happens on summer Thursday afternoons at various Cape May B&Bs, and seeking out scary tales for the “Ghosts of Christmas Past” trolley tours, Stahlhuth had amassed an exceptional collection. “I had my own personal rolodex,” she said.
So, in 2005, Stahlhuth assembled a few of those treasures into the first “Yuletide Tales” and the show has now become a Cape May seasonal staple.
“I just look deeply into American literature,” she said, “and find stories that can be adapted and performed.”
Some, like “Gift of the Magi,” are well-known and well-loved classics. But others are less familiar, and Stahlhuth delights in bringing these discoveries to the audience. “There are so many terrific stories out there. So, each year, I make sure to include at least one that I haven’t done before.” This year’s premier is Hawthorne’s “Snow Image.”
With such a substantial collection of literature from which to choose, how does Stahlhuth pare it down to the ones she will present?
“The performance lasts a little over an hour – with no intermission – so it is important that each story flows smoothly into the next,” she said.
Having that rhythm in mind, Stahlhuth chooses the stories. “Even when they are different in style or tone from one another, they need to go together well.”
In true storyteller fashion, Stahlhuth plays every character in every story, and performs completely from memory.
Does that mean that every performance features a word-for-word rendition? “No, they’re not verbatim,” she said. “Each one has a different shift.
“If, one night, a character wants to talk longer, and it’s within the context of the story, then that’s what happens.”
Stahlhuth also explained that an important aspect of what she does is to really get inside of each character. “I literally ‘see’ every person I am doing and the place where they are.”
While skilled at adapting works of literature for the stage, she is always careful to maintain the integrity of the writer.
“I am respectful of each writer’s style,” said Stahlhuth, “and aware of phraseology and word choices that are pivotal to the story.
“It’s like playing a composer’s music,” she explained. “You don’t just throw in something that the person didn’t intend to be there.”
Since 1999, the company has held its performances at the First Presbyterian Church of Cape May, located at 500 Hughes Street. And, as for all the shows, staging for “Yuletide Tales” is not elaborate – red drapes, a wreath, a table and three chairs make up the set.
This simple approach serves both artistic and practical purposes. A basic set allows the audience to focus on what is happening on stage and become immersed in the stories.
And, because the stage is also the church sanctuary, sets from the Saturday night performance need to make way the next morning for Sunday services. “We don’t construct anything that can’t be taken down in an hour,” she said.
In fact, the space serves the company very well. “It’s quite intimate and the acoustics are fantastic,” she said. “And since it’s a semi in-the-round arrangement, with no center aisle, the actors are always looking at people.”
Stahlhuth said the church and ELTC have struck a very compatible partnership. “They consider our company part of their mission,”
East Lynne Theater Company will present “Yuletide Tales” four more times this season: 8:00 p.m. on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday, December 8 through December 10, with a 2:00 p.m. matinee on Saturday, December 10. Tickets are $27 for adults, $17 for full-time students and military personnel and free for children 12 and under.
About the author: Jersey Girl, music lover, and culture geek – Shen Shellenberger has made a career of her life-long love of the arts. From her jobs at WXPN-FM and the Philadelphia Museum of Art, to her 25 years as a freelance writer, she instills her Jersey-born roots in all she does. Whether it’s the beauty of a classic painting, the dynamics of contemporary dance, or the raw energy of rock ‘n’ roll, Shen brings her perspective to whatever she covers.
Content provided by
Discover Jersey Arts, a project of the ArtPride New Jersey Foundation and New Jersey State Council on the Arts.
EVENT PREVIEWS
Centenary Stage Company presents a Staged Reading of "Big Money" on April 1st
(HACKETTSTOWN, NJ) -- Centenary Stage Company presents a staged reading of Big Money by Lauren Ferebee on Wednesday, April 1, 2026 at 7:00pm in the Sitnik Theatre as part of its Women Playwrights Series (WPS). This is a sharp and timely new play that dives into the high-stakes world of advertising, ambition, and moral compromise.
Who Is Karen Andre? Ruth Stage Brings Ayn Rand's "Night of January 16th" to Asbury Park!
(ASBURY PARK, NJ) -- Ruth Stage continues its residency at the Jersey Shore Arts Center with Night of January 16th, presented from April 2-4, 2026. This follows the company's acclaimed productions of Edward Albee's The Zoo Story and At Home at the Zoo. In Ayn Rand's gripping courtroom drama, Karen Andre stands accused of murdering her powerful and enigmatic lover, Bjorn Faulkner.
Passage Theatre Company to Hold Ribbon Cutting Ceremony for The Larry Hilton Stage on April 8th
(TRENTON, NJ) -- Passage Theatre Company is proud to host the naming of the Mill Hill Playhouse stage, to forevermore be known as "The Larry Hilton Stage," in honor of great donor, patron, producer and friend of the company Lawrence M. Hilton. Mr. Hilton was a beacon for Passage Theatre for nearly 40 years and a steward for all art, music, theater, and education in his hometown of Trenton, NJ.
Lewis Center for the Arts' Program in Theater & Music Theater presents "The Comeuppance" by Branden Jacobs-Jenkins
(PRINCETON, NJ) -- The Lewis Center for the Arts' Program in Theater and Music Theater at Princeton University presents The Comeuppance by Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award-winning playwright and Princeton alumnus Branden Jacobs-Jenkins, Class of 2006. Performances take place April 3-4 and April 10 at 8:00pm and April 11 at 2:00pm & 8:00pm at the Berlind Theatre at McCarter Theatre Center.
"It's Never Too Late," A New Musical Exploring Hope and Second Chances, Debuts at Kelsey Theatre in April
(WEST WINDSOR, NJ) -- The power of hope, reinvention, and second chances takes the stage when Theater To Go presents the world premiere, limited engagement of the new Lou DiPietro musical It's Never Too Late, across two weekends from April 3–12, 2026 at the Kelsey Theatre on the Mercer County Community College West Windsor Campus.
Brundage Park Playhouse presents "Titanic, The Musical"
(RANDOLPH, NJ) -- Brundage Park Playhouse presents Titanic, The Musical from April 9-12, 2026. Epic and majestic, with moments of heartbreaking intimacy, Titanic captures the triumph and tragedy of the hopeful passengers on the ill-fated Ship of Dreams.
Roundtable Theater Company presents "Jagged Little Pill"
(FAIR LAWN, NJ) -- Roundtable Theater Company presents the Tony and Grammy Award-winning musical Jagged Little Pill from April 9-12, 2026 at the George Frey Center for Performing Arts in the Fair Lawn Community Center. Set in modern-day Connecticut, this contemporary musical utilizes the genius of Alanis Morissette's 1995 album of the same name to tackle some of today's most important issues.
Centenary Stage Company presents 2026 Women Playwrights Series in April
(HACKETTSTOWN, NJ) -- Centenary Stage Company presents the 2026 Women Playwrights Series (WPS) across three Wednesdays from April 1-15. This year's series will feature staged readings of Big Money by Lauren Ferebee; Breeders by Megan Campisi; and Not It! by Kathleen Coudle-King.
RVCC to Present Student Theatre Production of "The Wolves"
(BRANCHBURG, NJ) -- Raritan Valley Community College's Arts & Design department will present The Wolves by Sarah DeLappe, April 15-17, 2026 at 7:00pm each night The performances, which are free of charge and open to the public, will be held in the Welpe Theatre at the College's Branchburg campus.
Bridgewater-Raritan High School Theatre Arts presents "Little Shop of Horrors"
(BRIDGEWATER, NJ) -- Bridgewater-Raritan High School Theatre Arts presents Little Shop of Horrors from April 16–18, 2026, in the Bridgewater-Raritan High School Auditorium. This cult-favorite musical comedy features a book and lyrics by Howard Ashman and music by Alan Menken, and tells the delightfully dark story of a shy flower shop assistant who discovers a mysterious plant with an insatiable appetite.
