New Jersey Stage
New Jersey Stage on social media

This article is from our magazine. To view it in its original format, click here

REVIEW: "Ad Astra"

By Eric Hillis,

originally published: 09/24/2019

REVIEW: "Ad Astra"

Steven Spielberg has long maintained that had he made Close Encounters of the Third Kind after marrying and having kids, it would have ended very differently. After becoming a family man, Spielberg balked at the idea that a father and husband would walk away from his family and take a ride off into the great unknown with a bunch of aliens. Has writer/director James Gray become a family man in the short time between his previous movie, 2016’s The Lost City of Z, and his latest, Ad Astra? His new film plays like something of a thematic rejoinder to his last one.

Both movies are about exploration. The Lost City of Z was based on the real life exploits of British explorer Percy Fawcett, who disappeared in the Amazon while searching for a rumoured ancient civilisation deep in the jungle. Gray’s film dealt heavily with the issue of how Fawcett spent so much time in the jungle that he missed out on his son’s childhood, but the euphoric way Gray staged the movie’s final scene suggested that the filmmaker’s sympathies lay with Fawcett. Conversely, Ad Astra makes it abundantly clear - too often through its intrusively didactic voiceover - that there’s no place like home.

Ad Astra is a work of fiction, but continues the theme of exploration, and both movies feature protagonists burdened by the actions of their fathers. In Lost City, Fawcett’s father was an alcoholic gambler who muddied the family name in the eyes of British high society. In Ad Astra, a father once again leaves his son behind in search of new worlds. This time it’s Clifford McBride (Tommy Lee Jones), an astronaut who disappears somewhere in deep space after travelling where no one has gone before. Almost three decades later his son, Roy (Brad Pitt), has followed in his father’s moon boots and is himself a high ranking astronaut. When Earth is impacted by a series of power surges that seem to be emanating from a source in deep space, Roy is delivered the news that his superiors believe Clifford is still alive, has murdered his fellow crew members and has gone all Colonel Kurtz, possibly controlling the power surges. Roy struggles to buy this, but agrees to embark on a mission to track down his old man.

REVIEW: "Ad Astra"

Filmmakers have long used space exploration as a front for examining very earthly concerns. Sometimes you have to float thousands of miles above Earth to really appreciate our pale blue dot and all that. Ad Astra suffers in comparison to the work of Kubrick and Tarkovsky whenever it decides to indulge its more philosophical side. Its message is little more than a sci-fi riff on the groan-worthy conclusion of Paulo Coelho’s insufferable novel The Alchemist, that sometimes you have to travel a long way to realise what you have at home. This wouldn’t be so bad if the movie delivered this far from original concept in an organic fashion, allowing the audience to gradually draw such a conclusion, rather than shoving it down our throats from the off. With its emotionally withdrawn astronaut protagonist, Ad Astra invites comparisons to last year’s Neil Armstrong biopic First Man, but it never quite reaches the emotional heights of Damien Chazelle’s film.

Ad Astra had its release delayed several times, and listening to Pitt constantly tell us what the movie is about through the worst voiceover in a sci-fi movie since the original release of Blade Runner will have you wondering if the narration was added at the insistence of the studio, possibly a result of Disney’s takeover of Twentieth Century Fox. The voiceover doesn’t add anything to the movie, rather it detracts from it, treating the audience as though we’re a bunch of visual illiterates who can’t process and make sense of images. At one point McBride lands on the moon, where the docking station resembles a provincial airport, replete with a Subway sandwich bar and and an Applebees. The picture tells us all we need to know about colonisation, but just in case we weren’t paying attention we have to endure a lecture on said issue via the narration. The voiceover distracts from what is a fantastic, subtle performance from Pitt, one that I’d likely be proclaiming his career best, had I not seen Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. Pitt’s expressive face speaks more truth to his character than his reductive voiceover, and it’s a shame that we’re left to imagine some future DVD cut that excises the narration.

The article continues after this ad


If at its worst, Ad Astra is Tarkovsky for dummies, at its best it’s a thrilling and thoughtful space adventure, one that features action set-pieces that are infinitely more exciting than anything found in the recent Star Wars films. The movie opens with a vertigo inducing sequence that sees McBride step out onto a giant antenna that reaches up through the clouds and into near space - see it on an IMAX screen and you’ll be wishing the seats came equipped with a safety harness. Elsewhere there’s a set-piece that makes the silly sounding idea of space piracy a very real, very scary reality.

REVIEW: "Ad Astra"

Visually, Gray and cinematographer Hoyte van Hoytema (the latter also responsible for the look of Christopher Nolan’s thematically similar but superior Interstellar) appear to take inspiration from the under-rated sci-fi movies of Peter Hyams (Capricorn One, Outland, 2010), delivering a very 1970s vision of the future, all orange plastic furniture and Scandinavian inspired interiors. On the aural front, Max Richter’s moody score captures the mix of awe and uncertainty at the heart of space exploration, while the under-played sound design reflects the eerie tranquility of the void. If Ad Astra never quite massages the mind as much as it might like, it certainly stirs the senses.

Ad Astra   3 1/2 Stars Out Of 5

Director: James Gray; Starring: Brad Pitt, Liv Tyler, Ruth Negga, Donald Sutherland,  Tommy Lee Jones

For more by this author, click here

More Articles You Might Like

NJPAC Presents "Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince" In Concert With NJSO
NJPAC Presents "Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince" In Concert With NJSO
Theater to Go at Kelsey Theatre presents A Sing and Play Along Screening Of "Annie"
Theater to Go at Kelsey Theatre presents A Sing and Play Along Screening Of "Annie"
The Home Of Happiness To Present "The Rocky Horror Picture Show" In Newton
The Home Of Happiness To Present "The Rocky Horror Picture Show" In Newton
REVIEW: "Ad Astra"
REVIEW: "Ad Astra"
Shield: Superheroes Do Exist
Shield: Superheroes Do Exist
REVIEW: "Hustlers"
REVIEW: "Hustlers"

Event calendar
Saturday, Oct 19, 2019


MELVIN SEALS & JGB FEATURING JOHN KADLECIK @ The Stone Pony, Asbury Park - 7:00pm

THE BILSBY BROTHERS @ The Saint, Asbury Park - 7:30pm

Reock & Roll Revue | A Tribute to Chicago II @ The Millstone Performing Arts Center, Millstone - 7:30pm

Eaglemania @ The Levoy Theatre, Millville - 8:00pm

Last Whispers @ Alexander Kasser Theater, Montclair - 8:00pm

RICK SPRINGFIELD & RICHARD MARX @ The Wellmont Theater, Montclair - 7:00pm

KIP MOORE: ROOM TO SPARE ACOUSTIC TOUR @ Mayo Performing Arts Center (MPAC), Morristown - 8:00pm

American Song -Disney and the Boys: Will and Anthony Nunziata sing the Sherman Brothers @ The Chase Room @ New Jersey Performing Arts Center (NJPAC), Newark - 6:00pm and 8:30pm

Soulshine: An Allman Brothers Experience @ Victoria Theater @ New Jersey Performing Arts Center (NJPAC), Newark - 8:00pm

TOTO @ Count Basie Center For The Arts, Red Bank - 8:00pm

Floyd Pink @ Lizzie Rose Music Room, Tuckerton - 7:30pm

Annie Sing-Along! @ Kelsey Theatre at Mercer County Community College, West Windsor Township - 10:00am


East Lynne Theater Company presents POE BY CANDLELIGHT @ First Presbyterian Church (Cape May), Cape May - 8:00pm

Monster Princess Tales @ West Hudson Arts & Theatre Co, Kearny - 3:00pm

House on Haunted Hill (World Premiere) @ Burgdorff Center for the Performing Arts, Maplewood - 4:00pm and 7:30pm

Chasing Rainbows: The Road To Oz @ Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn - 1:30pm and 8:00pm

Theater of Fear @ The Mill Race Theatrical Company, Mount Holly - 1:30pm and 7:30pm

Our Town @ Jay & Linda Grunin Center For The Arts At Ocean County College, Toms River - 8:00pm

The Late Christopher Bean continues at WCP @ Westfield Community Players, Westfield - 8:00pm


Get Happy! Hollywood Hits from Harold Arlen @ The Avenel Performing Arts Center, Avenel - 8:00pm

Comedian Kevin Downey Jr @ Brook Arts Center, Bound Brook - 8:00pm

THE JIM BREUER RESIDENCY @ Bergen Performing Arts Center (bergenPAC), Englewood - 8:00pm

Jo Koy @ Prudential Hall @ New Jersey Performing Arts Center (NJPAC), Newark - 8:00pm


Nimbus Dance: 15th Anniversary Crystal Gala 2019 @ Harborside Atrium, Jersey City - 7:00pm



View all events


New Jersey Stage © 2019 by Wine Time Media, LLC | PO Box 140, Spring Lake, NJ 07762 |

Images used on this site have been sent to us from publicists, artists, and PR firms.
If there is a problem with the rights to any image, please contact us and we will look into the matter.