New Jersey Stage
New Jersey Stage on social media

Big News! New Jersey Stage Releases Three Fall Preview Guides
Click here to see them!

Makin Waves with The Cryptkeeper Five:
Sonic Truth!

originally published: 09/18/2019

Makin Waves with The Cryptkeeper Five: Sonic Truth!

The Cryptkeeper Five premiere their new single, a cover of The Sonics’ “Strychnine,” this week at New Jersey Stage and its Penguin Rocks show “Radio Jersey.” PHOTO BY ANTHONY VITO COSENTINO

Earlier this week on’s “Radio Jersey” show, Trenton-based The Cryptkeeper Five premiered their new single, a cover of punk prototype The Sonic’s 1965 classic “Strychnine,” made famous 15 years later by The Cramps. The YouTube track premieres below.

But first a big shout to one of my favorite Jersey bands, a Makin Waves Dirty Dozen act and co-winners of the 2018 Makin Waves Songwriter of the Year Award with pals in The Vansaders. More vital than ever after 22 years slugging it out in the scene, TCK5 have lot going on, which front man Johnny Ott chats about on behalf of band mates: co-founding guitarist Jimmy Harrington Jr., bassist Mikey Groch, drummer Brian Mazzarini and keyboardist Buzzy. 

The band will play a hot, hot show with Hub City Stompers and The Toasters on Sept. 21 at Neshaminy Creek Brewing in Croydon, Pa. On Sept. 27, after years of playing the old Asbury Lanes, they’ll make their debut at the renovated Lanes opening for celebrated punk bands Strung Out and The Casualties. They’ll also play Oct. 18 at Snub Fest in D.C., Halloween night at The Sparrow in North Charleston, S.C., and two early November dates at The Fest in Florida before heading back home to play Philly’s The TUSK with The Big Bad.  

The Cryptkeeper Five have been around a long time in various incarnations. What is the current lineup and what do you enjoy most about playing with them?
Jimmy Ray, who’s been around since day one, on guitar; Mikey Groch on bass; Brian Mazzarini on drums and Buzzy on keys. I like everything about playing with these guys. As a singer-songwriter, I wholeheartedly can say I couldn’t ask for a more talented group of guys to work with. They’re also my best friends.

Makin Waves with The Cryptkeeper Five: Sonic Truth!

Johnny Ott, left, and Jimmy Harrington Jr., right, are the co-founders of The Cryptkeeper Five and the band’s only original members. PHOTO BY ERIC BLAIR

The only other original member of the band is your longtime friend Jimmy Harrington. How did you guys meet and what has kept you buds on and off the stage for so long?
Hah! I met Jimmy, probably, when we were 9 or 10. We were just kids that crossed paths in the neighborhood. We became good friends around 13 in middle school. There weren’t many kids into punk or metal at our school, so I think we kinda gravitated towards each other. We started playing in a band around 16. We’ve never not played in a band together since. We’re brothers at this point. I can’t imagine my life without him in it.

You’ve had a good year with touring, singles, a video and splattered vinyl. You have two more singles coming out in as many months. Both are covers. What are they, why did you want to cover them, when will they be released, and how will you promote them?
‘Strychnine’ by The Sonics is the next TCK5 single coming out. I think on Spotify on Sept. 23. I’ve always loved the song. I’ve been a big Cramps fan since I was a teenager, which led me to The Sonics’ version, and once I heard theirs, I knew TCK5 had to do a version.

The video was for ‘10,000 Keys,’ which chronicles the release of punk rock in the face of family dysfunction. What inspired that song and video and how does it make you feel to play it live?
Haha! I guess always wanted to set my father on fire. Just kidding.  The song and video are sort of autobiographical. Growing up in my household wasn’t the easiest, but in all honesty, as I get older, I know it could have been a whole lot worse. I LOVE playing it live.

Tell me about that splattered vinyl of your latest LP, ‘Stronghold,’ and how folks can get their hands on it.
Our friends at Say-10 Records released it. I’m not sure how many splattered versions are left, but their also selling a limited white version as well. It has a different last song then the one we self-released. We changed out ‘Two-Headed Boy,’ originally by Neutral Milk Hotel, with a cover of Arcade Fire’s ‘Wake Up.’ You can still get copies at

‘Stronghold’ is one of my all-time favorite LPs by a Jersey band. When and how do you plan to follow that up and how is the process going?
We plan on starting a new album by early 2020. Not sure exactly when, but we’re pretty excited. I think it’s going to be pretty great.

How has Sean Glonek of SRG Studios and many fellow Trenton bands been an influence on you and TCK5 over the years and what does he bring to the Cryptkeeper table that wouldn’t be there without him?
I completely trust Sean’s opinion. He just understands our band. His perspective of the songs is invaluable. He’s completely straight forward and direct with us. If something sucks, he has absolutely no problem with letting us know it ... no dancing around it, a simple, ‘That sucks, That’s why we’re leaving it out!’ He’s usually right. We need someone like that!

Your Neshaminy Creek show with Hub City Stompers and The Toasters looks great. It reminds me of the Makin Waves show we did last summer at Asbury Park Brewery with HCS, Molly Rhythm, Experiment 34 and Chalk & the Beige Americans. How and why are TCK5/HCS shows must-see super fun?
Hub City Stompers are great! I think we’re pretty great. Two great bands on a bill is better than just one.

The other band I’ve loved pairing you with are Asbury-based The Vansaders with whom you play frequently and recently toured. Why is there a special relationship between the two bands and what do you like most about The Vansaders?
The Vansaders are not only an amazing band, they’re also amazing guys: fun, sweet guys. I feel we’re cut from the same cloth. We’re both a little bit punk, a little bit rock ‘n’ roll, a tiny bit country. Our little tour we did with them was one of the easiest, most light-hearted times we’ve spent away from home.  I can’t wait to do more with them in 2020.

You’ve played the old Lanes a bunch of times, but is the Sept. 27 show the first time you’ve played the new Lanes? If so, how and why is that a special gig?
This will be our first time. It should be a great show. We’re supporting two fairly celebrated punk bands, Strung Out and The Casualties. We’re pretty excited.

What are you looking forward most about playing The Fest and have you ever played it before?
It’s our first time. We’re really excited though. I’m honestly not sure what I’m most excited about. I’m just excited.

What else will be going on with TCK5 the rest of the year and into next?
Demoing, hopefully shooting another video (maybe two). A small tour around Fest. A Thanksgiving Eve Millhill show. A Christmas Millhill show. Recording a new album.  Whatever else gets thrown our way between now and then. It’s fairly busy. Even when I feel we’re not, we are.

How are The Mighty John Caseys, your duo with your nephew, Joey, doing? What plans do you have with that?
It’s good. I love it. I want to record soon.

Joey is your manager. What does he and DIMM Entertainment do for the band that you couldn’t do yourselves?
DIMM are great. Joey and Matt have done a lot for us. A lot of doors have been opened for TCK5 over the past two years. Say-10. Fest. They have our backs.

Is there anything I didn’t ask on which you would like to comment?
Nope. Thanks Bob. Your support has been greatly appreciated.  


Makin Waves with The Cryptkeeper Five: Sonic Truth! 


Bob Makin is the reporter for and a former managing editor of The Aquarian Weekly, which launched this column in 1988. Contact him at And like Makin Waves at

For more by this author, click here

More Articles You Might Like

Celine Dion To Perform At Prudential Center On March 7, 2020
Celine Dion To Perform At Prudential Center On March 7, 2020
Prudential Center Presents Bad Bunny
Prudential Center Presents Bad Bunny
The Outlaws To Perform At Newton Theatre On November 2nd
The Outlaws To Perform At Newton Theatre On November 2nd
Tusk Comes to The Newton Theatre On November 23
Tusk Comes to The Newton Theatre On November 23
Prudential Center Adds Second Show For Celine Dion
Prudential Center Adds Second Show For Celine Dion
Soulshine: An Allman Brothers Experience Comes To NJPAC On October 19
Soulshine: An Allman Brothers Experience Comes To NJPAC On October 19

Event calendar
Saturday, Oct 19, 2019


MELVIN SEALS & JGB FEATURING JOHN KADLECIK @ The Stone Pony, Asbury Park - 7:00pm

THE BILSBY BROTHERS @ The Saint, Asbury Park - 7:30pm

Reock & Roll Revue | A Tribute to Chicago II @ The Millstone Performing Arts Center, Millstone - 7:30pm

Eaglemania @ The Levoy Theatre, Millville - 8:00pm

Last Whispers @ Alexander Kasser Theater, Montclair - 8:00pm

RICK SPRINGFIELD & RICHARD MARX @ The Wellmont Theater, Montclair - 7:00pm

KIP MOORE: ROOM TO SPARE ACOUSTIC TOUR @ Mayo Performing Arts Center (MPAC), Morristown - 8:00pm

American Song -Disney and the Boys: Will and Anthony Nunziata sing the Sherman Brothers @ The Chase Room @ New Jersey Performing Arts Center (NJPAC), Newark - 6:00pm and 8:30pm

Soulshine: An Allman Brothers Experience @ Victoria Theater @ New Jersey Performing Arts Center (NJPAC), Newark - 8:00pm

TOTO @ Count Basie Center For The Arts, Red Bank - 8:00pm

Floyd Pink @ Lizzie Rose Music Room, Tuckerton - 7:30pm

Annie Sing-Along! @ Kelsey Theatre at Mercer County Community College, West Windsor Township - 10:00am


East Lynne Theater Company presents POE BY CANDLELIGHT @ First Presbyterian Church (Cape May), Cape May - 8:00pm

Monster Princess Tales @ West Hudson Arts & Theatre Co, Kearny - 3:00pm

House on Haunted Hill (World Premiere) @ Burgdorff Center for the Performing Arts, Maplewood - 4:00pm and 7:30pm

Chasing Rainbows: The Road To Oz @ Paper Mill Playhouse, Millburn - 1:30pm and 8:00pm

Theater of Fear @ The Mill Race Theatrical Company, Mount Holly - 1:30pm and 7:30pm

Our Town @ Jay & Linda Grunin Center For The Arts At Ocean County College, Toms River - 8:00pm

The Late Christopher Bean continues at WCP @ Westfield Community Players, Westfield - 8:00pm


Get Happy! Hollywood Hits from Harold Arlen @ The Avenel Performing Arts Center, Avenel - 8:00pm

Comedian Kevin Downey Jr @ Brook Arts Center, Bound Brook - 8:00pm

THE JIM BREUER RESIDENCY @ Bergen Performing Arts Center (bergenPAC), Englewood - 8:00pm

Jo Koy @ Prudential Hall @ New Jersey Performing Arts Center (NJPAC), Newark - 8:00pm


Nimbus Dance: 15th Anniversary Crystal Gala 2019 @ Harborside Atrium, Jersey City - 7:00pm



View all events


New Jersey Stage © 2019 by Wine Time Media, LLC | PO Box 140, Spring Lake, NJ 07762 |

Images used on this site have been sent to us from publicists, artists, and PR firms.
If there is a problem with the rights to any image, please contact us and we will look into the matter.