By Gary Wien
originally published: 02/11/2016
(NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ) — George Street Playhouse opened a wonderful production of Nureyev’s Eyes by David Rush last week. It is a fascinating fictional account of the relationship between the painter Jamie Wyeth and the Russian ballet dancer Rudolf Nureyev. The play stars William Connell (Wyeth) and Bill Dawes (Nureyev). From the moment they hit the stage, the world becomes one of two tortured artists. One who seeks to rise to the standards set by his family of famous artists; the other who fights comparisons to his lover for the title best dancer in the world.
“My name is Jamie Wyeth, I’m a painter. I want to do your portrait and I wasn’t sure until just now,” says Wyeth upon meeting Nureyev.
Nureyev is reluctant at first, telling him that “you can’t paint dancer… ballet is dancer moving.” But Wyeth persists, even setting up a meeting under false pretenses. Eventually, they come to an agreement - mainly because they both have specific goals that the other can help with. Nureyev wants Wyeth’s connection to Lincoln Kirstein, the co-founder of the New York City Ballet, and Wyeth wants Nureyev to be the subject that will elevate his career.
Directed by Michael Mastro, George Street Playhouse’s Resident Artistic Director, the play moves at a swift pace. It runs 90 minutes without an intermission and Mastro keeps the action at a very high and sometimes frenetic pace. Both actors are exceptional, revealing both the confidence of their character as well as their fears.
One of the best scenes in the play is the negotiation between the two regarding the painting. Nureyev spouts out a laundry list of demands, yet Wyeth goes toe to toe with him. After hearing his list, Wyeth confidently shoots down each demand, ultimately saying, “I don’t tell you how to dance, don’t tell me how to paint!”
In real life, Wyeth is known to have sketched hundreds of drawings of Nureyev over the course of several years. In an interview with the New York Times in 2002, he described Nureyev as “one of the most demanding and fascinating assignments he had ever taken. He wanted to capture ‘this phantom figure,’ he said, a goal that was complicated by Nureyev's obsessiveness about his art and himself.”
A funny thing happens along the way; as Nureyev sits for Wyeth time after time and months pass, the two become friends. Both sense the greatness within each other and recognize the potential that could come from the painting; Wyeth knows he can finally be seen as a true member of his family’s artistic legacy and Nureyev can gain the immortality he has long sought.
Wyeth probes Nureyev along the way, determined to learn his secrets and discover what drives his passion. His answers are like riddles into his soul. When asked what is your happiest day he responds, “tomorrow, always tomorrow.” Nureyev, who defected to the United States, also reveals his greatest fear — the KGB hunting him down. “The only place I’m free is on stage,” he says.
Nureyev’s secret is in his eyes, Wyeth believes. His questions are always given with the hope of capturing the truth hidden inside. Part of his obsessiveness with the sketches is a quest for an image that will accurately portray Nureyev’s eyes and lead to his masterpiece.
Their friendship is partially built by the personal demons they both share. Wyeth constantly hears a voice that tells him that he cannot paint, he doesn’t match up to his family’s name and never will. Nureyev’s voice goes even farther, telling him that he will fall and he will drop his partner.
“Your voice is a lot more aggressive than mine,” said Wyeth. “He’s Russian,” is the response.
It's not important to know much about ballet or art to enjoy this play. There are a few mentions of specific dancers and paintings, but the story is truly about these two characters. Whether or not you know Wyeth's family story or the dancers that Nureyev compares himself to will not take away from the plot.
The play is a perfect blend of drama and comedy. Beautiful lighting changes lure us into the minds and moods of these artists, showcasing everything from their joy to madness. The lighting is such an integral part of the production it is practically a character of its own. Through the ups and downs of an often intense relationship, the play ultimately begs the questions: how much does an artist need to know about his subject in order to capture them on a canvas? An how much do they need to know about themselves?
Nureyev’s Eyes is running now through February 21 at George Street Playhouse (9 Livingston Avenue) in New Brunswick, NJ. For more information visit www.gsponline.org
Photos by T. Charles Erickson
Gary Wien has been covering the arts since 2001 and has had work published with Jersey Arts, Upstage Magazine, Elmore Magazine, Princeton Magazine, Backstreets and other publications. He is a three-time winner of the Asbury Music Award for Top Music Journalist and the author of
Beyond the Palace (the first book on the history of rock and roll in Asbury Park) and
Are You Listening? The Top 100 Albums of 2001-2010 by New Jersey Artists. In addition, he runs New Jersey Stage and the online radio station
The Penguin Rocks. His personal website is at
lightyscorner.com. He can be contacted at
[email protected].
EVENT PREVIEWS
Nutley Little Theatre to Hold Auditions for "Asuncion" by Jesse Eisenberg
(NUTLEY, NJ) -- Nutley Little Theatre will hold auditions for Jesse Eisenberg's 2011 play Asuncion on Sunday, April 23 and Monday, April 24, 2026 from 6:30pm-9:00pm. The production will be directed and produced by Craig Tiede.
Centenary Stage Company to Hold Non-Union Auditions for Nextstage Repertory Summer 2026 Season
(HACKETTSTOWN, NJ) -- Centenary Stage Company is seeking non-equity singer/actors who are excellent movers/dancers for the 2026 NEXTStage Repertory 2026 Summer Season. The summer season includes The Wedding Singer and Maltby & Shire's Closer Than Ever. Auditions will be held by appointment on Saturday, April 25, 2026 from 10:00am–4:00pm in the Lackland Performing Arts Center.
Bordentown Thespians present "The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical"
(BORDENTOWN, NJ) -- The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical, with music and lyrics by Rob Rokicki and book by Joe Tracz, will be presented on Saturday, April 25th at 2:00pm & 6:30pm at the Bordentown Performing Arts Center. As the half-blood son of a Greek god, Percy Jackson has newly discovered powers he can't control, a destiny he doesn't want, and a mythology textbook's worth of monsters on his trail.
The Growing Stage presents their 2026 New Play-Reading Festival
(NETCONG, NJ) -- The Growing Stage presents their 2026 New Play-Reading Festival from April 23-25, 2026 at The Historic Palace Theatre. The festival presents four unpublished and unproduced Theatre for Young Audiences scripts. This year features works by Samara Siskind, Martin Follose, Grace Ward & Elke Myers, and Jeff Jenkins.
2026 Jersey Shore Young Playwrights Festival to Take Place April 25th
(TOMS RIVER, NJ) -- Stargazer Performing Arts is proud to announce the plays and playwrights for the 2026 Jersey Shore Young Playwrights Festival. This is the second year for the festival which showcases original plays written by students ages 13 to 18. Staged reading of the plays will premiere on Saturday, April 25 in the Gia Maione Prima Black Box Theatre at the Grunin Performing Arts Academy in Toms River.
American Theater Group to Honor Co-Founder/Producing Artistic Director James Vagias at Gala Benefit
(UNION, NJ) -- American Theater Group (ATG) will honor its outgoing co-founder and Producing Artistic Director James Vagias at its bi-annual Gala Benefit on Sunday, April 26, 2026, at the Union Arts Center. Vagias will retire this summer at the end of the 2025-26 Season. A successor will be named shortly.
Old Library Theatre presents "Julius Caesar"
(WAYNE, NJ) -- Old Library Theatre presents Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare from April 24-26, 2026. You know the story. The Ides of March. The societal unrest.
Freehold Jewish Center presents NJ Premiere Reading of "The Silence of Our Friends" by Gary Morgenstein
(FREEHOLD, NJ) — The Freehold Jewish Center (Congregation Agudath Achim) will present the New Jersey premiere reading of award-winning playwright Gary Morgenstein's provocative new play The Silence of Our Friends on Sunday, April 26, 2026 at 2:00pm as a special fundraising event with all ticket proceeds going to the synagogue.
Dragonfly Multicultural Arts Center presents 2026 New Jersey One-Act Play Festival
(PLAINFIELD, NJ) -- Dragonfly Multicultural Arts Center presents its 2026 New Jersey One-Act Play Festival, featuring five world premiere one-act plays by New Jersey playwrights, from April 24-26, 2026 at duCret Center of Art. The annual festival continues Dragonfly's mission of championing local artists, producing new work, and bringing diverse, community-centered storytelling to the stage.
Studio Players' Reading Series presents a staged reading of "Othello" on Sunday
(UPPER MONTCLAIR, NJ) -- Studio Players' Reading Series presents a staged reading of Othello on Sunday, April 26, 2026 at 7:00pm. Othello is one of Shakespeare’s most powerful and enduring tragedies—a riveting story of love, jealousy, betrayal, and the devastating cost of misplaced trust.
